Would dismantling Interstate 980 repair damage to Black neighborhoods? But two public schools with open campuses, like CSU also have taken the step: New Jerseys Rutgers University and Colorados Fort Lewis College. "Colleges have the legal authority to require proof of vaccination for students (and already require that students be vaccinated against MMR [measles, mumps and rubella], meningitis, and other vaccine-preventable diseases), but the emergency use authorization (EUA) status of the Covid-19 vaccines raises a wrinkle," Joanne Rosen, an associate But not at Inspire Charter School, where classes are held through third-party vendors, she said. We should get this approval on the fast track and vaccinate as much as we can. NCSL's new database that brings you up-to-date, real-time information about bills related to Emergency Medical Services. CCSA spokesperson Brittany Parmley said in an email that like Californias traditional district schools, charter public schools are required to comply with the law., A two-year moratorium on non-classroom-based charter schools is part of a new law authored this year by Assembly Education Chairman Patrick ODonnell (D-Long Beach), who said the vaccine loophole is just another example of how charter schools operate like the Wild West., Ill be blunt, I think a lot of those folks have either disdain for the government or deep religious convictions that lead them to not put their children in public schools, ODonnell said. California community colleges set their policies individually, but several indicated that their boards now are reconsidering their COVID vaccine requirements. Disease prevention has shifted in that time from public health requirements to individual . We know people who are vaccinated can still spread it, Noymer said. California University of Pennsylvania is a member of the Pennsylvania State System of Higher Education, where David Pidgeon, public relations director for PASSHE, said universities in Pennsylvania don't have the legal authority to mandate students and employees get the COVID vaccine because no legislation specifically provides that authorization. California schools are operating safely; children are less likely to develop serious cases of COVID-19; and the vaccine is still being given under emergency use authorization for kids 5 to. by Elizabeth Aguilera April 15, 2022. The risk is very low. Lunchtime at ERCLC is a wonderful example of families and students of all ages interacting, having fun on the playground and enjoying lunch under the shade trees.. But a bill to accomplish that failed, and the California Department of Public health put the mandate off another year. Scott Adams faces 'consequence culture' as U.S. newspapers drop Dilbert, Tom Cruise's 'ditching' of Suri showcased by Judd Apatow's 'co-parenting' joke, ex-Scientology exec says. One of the last remaining questions was what would happen to the state's vaccine mandate for schoolchildren, a policy that came from the California Department of Public Health and was not impacted by the lifting of the emergency declaration. At least two dozen colleges have said that they will not require shots while the vaccines have only emergency authorization. He saidthe policy no longer seems necessary now that mask requirements have ended. Allowing only those who have undergone a particular medical intervention/treatment and banning those who haven't is not fair or equal treatment. Dr. Arthur Reingold, an epidemiology professor at UC-Berkeley, notes that UC also requires immunizations for measles and chickenpox, and people still are dying from COVID at rates that exceed those for influenza. Though many home-based charters bring students together for regular classroom instruction or activities, the state doesn't uniformly enforce vaccination laws for such programs. Miranda. Or are they going to say its not their problem? Jeffrey Nolan, an attorney with the firm Holland & Knight, said the key reason that colleges can require students to be vaccinated even before the vaccines get full approval is because students arent being forced to attend. WASHINGTON Federal health advisers on Tuesday narrowly backed an experimental vaccine from Pfizer that could soon become the first shot to protect older adults . Dr. Arthur Reingold, an epidemiology professor at UC-Berkeley, notes that UC also requires immunizations for measles and chickenpox, and people still are dying from COVID at rates that exceed those for influenza. We felt that we were moving in alignment with many other organizations that are requiring the vaccination, and our student population and their families have largely been quite supportive, said Avis Hinkson, that colleges dean of students. The much likelier explanation is that parents think the lower rates of serious illness among kids, especially elementary school age kids, means that the disease is less of a threat than these relatively new vaccines, about which theyre hearing a lot of misinformation. Californias Community Colleges: At a Crossroads, Adjuncts gig economy at CA community colleges, College And Covid: Freshman Year Disrupted, Education during Covid: California families struggle to learn, Tainted Taps: Lead puts California Students at Risk, Full Circle: California Schools Work To Transform Discipline, Californias Homeless Students: Undercounted, Underfunded And Growing, Eyes on the Early Years Newsletter Archive, joining Californias public university systems, several public universities across the country have joined the many private colleges, Click here for EdSource's Comments Policy, https://aapsonline.org/open-letter-from-physicians-to-universities-reverse-covid-vaccine-mandates/?fbclid=IwAR1kJC62206pWD0PGLxftD7sGgAvgstTRPF62oJIkXuEEylpsZwUzJfjcAU, College and Covid: Freshman Year Disrupted, Education During Covid: Families Struggle to Learn. I think were going to see legal challenges, but my sense is that this issue is very quickly becoming far less a legal issue or even a science and data and facts issue and its becoming a political issue, said Peter McDonough, the organizations vice president and general counsel. This page was reviewed on January 17, 2020. And theres still debate about how effective vaccines are at stopping infections among children. For a vaccine to be given full approval, one of those manufacturers would need to submit whats called a biologics license application to the FDA. Some host classes through third party vendors like the YMCA, which dont have to operate under the same laws that schools do. Meanwhile, the California Charter Schools Association is distancing itself from the issue after anti-vaccine opponents protested in Sacramento for weeks this summer, culminating in a woman being arrested for tossing a blood-filled menstrual cup on state senators during the final day of the legislative session. Though many home-based charters bring students together for regular classroom instruction or activities, the state doesnt uniformly enforce vaccination laws for such programs. While this situation could change drastically with infection rates again increasing because of a new subvariant, Pan made a sensible move earlier this month to hold off on his vaccine mandate bill. Start the day smarter Notable deaths in 2023 The world's . Its unclear how many employees and students have been blocked from campus because they were not vaccinated for COVID. By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the Terms of Service. Labarre, the San Diego mother, says each of her childrens schools has its own set of rules regarding vaccines. According to an email record provided to POLITICO, Russin told California Department of Education officials three years ago that she was very concerned about reports of some schools, some of which are public charters receiving public money, that have reorganized as home-school co-ops in an effort to evade the vaccination requirements. The risk is very low. If you have updated information concerning this table, please call (651) 647-9009 or email admin@immunize.org . Privacy Policy SACRAMENTO Nearly all California students must get vaccinated after state leaders tightened laws following the 2014 Disneyland measles scare, but at least one loophole remains: new hybrid programs known as charter home schools. But CSU campuses may require specific populations of students, such as athletes and dorm residents, to be vaccinated, added spokesman Michael Uhlenkamp. In some instances, schools could require that unvaccinated students study online, not in person. But most states did not follow California's lead when it came to the vaccine mandate for public schools. A vaccine mandate could drive many of them away from in-person learning. Gov. As of Feb. 1, there were more than 400 COVID deaths a day across the U.S. The argument in favor of mandatory vaccination for COVID is no different than the argument for mandatory vaccination for flu, measles and meningitis, Reingold said. Lisa also contributes to the Videography team. Samuel Merritt University Santa Barbara City College Santa Clara University Santa Rosa Junior College Scripps College Soka University of America Southern California Institute of Architecture Southwestern College Stanford University University of California system How can the university require such vaccines to take place without knowing the full effects that could happen to our children. But months later, a vaccine mandate for school-age children seems less urgent at least for the moment. The American Council on Education, a trade group representing college and university presidents, wrote in an issue brief that the legal right of institutions to require COVID-19 vaccination for students seems likely to be upheld even under an emergency use authorization as long as they allow for medical and religious exemptions, which Californias colleges and universities plan to do. But UC in December softened its booster requirement by allowing an opt-out, the same as for annual flu shots. The best thing for most students is to be in school and in a physical classroom; thats especially true for students who depend on school for nutritious meals, physical activity and at least some counseling. Other major private schools that will require vaccines this fall are New Yorks Ithaca College, Syracuse University and Manhattanville College; University of Notre Dame in Indiana, and Northeastern University in Boston, Massachusetts. The University of Colorado announced on April 28 that its four campuses and system administration will require all students, faculty and staff to have COVID vaccinations before the start of fall semester 2021. The number of unvaccinated children in public and private home-schooling has skyrocketed in California since the 2015 law was enacted. As the world has seen several times in the last two years, COVID-19 can turn on a dime. College COVID-19 vaccine requirements are facing renewed scrutiny now that California has walked back plans to mandate the shots in K-12 schools and the state and federal governments are ending their pandemic states of emergency. For Pan, its common sense: If students get together in the same place, they should have to be vaccinated, regardless if theyre technically classified as a home school. 17:170(A); 40:31.16, Okla. Stat. The California schools have said they will enforce their mandates only after full . CA won't require COVID vaccine to attend schools WHO to vote on ending COVID-19 pandemic declaration COVID-19 subvariant BQ.1 now in Fresno County, health officials say It has an immunization rate of 26 percent. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Chart: Bay Area rainfall totals for this week. This page was updated on February 19, 2020. Are these universities willing to step up and guarantee that they will be responsible for our childrens health issues that Read More. I was trying to find anybody who could claim responsibility for this, Russin said. They will all feel a little better if theres a vaccine requirement in place, but were up against a nebulous deadline in terms of the FDA approval, he said. USC and UC have said they expect full approval to happen over the summer. At CSU, with campuses stretching from the northernmost part of the state to San Diego, it will be left to each of the individual campuses and their local public health agencies to make those decisions, Uhlenkamp said. No final decisions have been made at this time, said spokesperson E.J. The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation Headquarters: 185 Berry St., Suite 2000, San Francisco, CA 94107 | Phone 650-854-9400 Washington Offices and Barbara Jordan Conference Center: 1330 G Street . This will be for the higher courts to decide. A 2015 law in California requiring vaccines among schoolchildren has also withstood legal challenges. Column: 15 minutes of fame flies by. Students say that, in some cases, verification procedures tripped up class registration. But its not zero. At Pomona College, a private college in Los Angeles County, administrators also determined that waiting for full approval wouldnt be necessary. SAN JOSE, Calif. College COVID-19 vaccine requirements are facing renewed scrutiny now that California has walked back plans to mandate the shots in K-12 schools and the state and Schools in the District of Columbia plan to require the COVID-19 vaccine starting in the fall. The state chancellors office that oversees those colleges is leaving it up to local college leaders to decide whether to mandate vaccines. At a growing number of colleges and universities around the U.S., getting a COVID-19 vaccination is a must for students who plan to return to campus this . Column: COVID deniers claim a new study says mask mandates don't work. At Stanford, we are in the process of evaluating whether we will have COVID-19 vaccination requirements for any on-campus populations once vaccines are fully and easily available to all. A parent group called No College Mandates has a spreadsheet to track the status of mandates at colleges across the country. The recent second wave of Covid-19 has spread in India and the government was not prepared. University of California law professor Dorit Rubinstein Reiss, who writes and teaches about vaccine law, said the biggest legal gray area is whether colleges can require the COVID-19 vaccines . The school offers on-site classes and field trips in addition to its homeschooling program. Pending full FDA approval, vaccines will be required this fall at Sacramento State and other public universities throughout California. But there remain ways to get around the law and still receive a taxpayer-funded education, even in California. For funding purposes, the state defines schools with less than 80 percent of on-site instruction time as non-classroom based, which some schools may rely upon to operate as if the vaccination rules dont apply to them. Charter schools are paid for by public tax dollars, so why are they not required to be as protected as every other school in the state?. The vaccine requirements proposed by the University of California and California State University systems came with a notable caveat: They will only take effect if the Food and Drug Administration gives full approval to one of the existing vaccines, something not guaranteed to happen by the fall. Theres a risk to the community because college students are mobile and can spread COVID-19 whenever they travel. A lot of families have been stressed from this decision and worried about it for quite some time," he said. According to California courts, it is legally permissible for public colleges to mandate a flu vaccine. There are unintended consequences when people are too draconian, telling a student you cant register for classes if youre not vaccinated.. Outside of work, she enjoys photography, backpacking, swimming and bird-watching. For a 20-year-old college student, how likely are they to die? Attempts to ban COVID-19 vaccine requirements are common among states. Turn on desktop notifications for breaking stories about interest? We know people who are vaccinated can still spread it, Noymer said. Already, universities require students to be vaccinated against illnesses such as measles and chickenpox. That lawyer's comment that schools can mandate students to vaccinate because they aren't "forced" to attend completely misses the legal duty schools have for "fair and equal treatment" of their students. Here are 10 you cant miss. Thats like if you had a term paper and there was no deadline and asking, when will you have that due?. Most California kids will kick off the 2020-2021 academic year with distance learning due to the coronavirus, but the state's strict vaccination laws . Will colleges keep requiring them? But anytime you have people congregating closely together for longer periods of time, thats what enables the spread of outbreaks, he said. Klausner, the professor of preventive medicine at USC, said whether wider reopenings would be safe without a vaccine requirement would depend on the spread of Covid-19 at the time. Nearly all of the pandemic restrictions put in place by Newsom have been lifted, and he won't be able to issue any new ones after Feb. 28 when the state's coronavirus emergency declaration officially ends. Read More. April 15, 2021 / 4:35 PM / MoneyWatch. Of the 50 largest public university campuses, 26 do not require vaccination, representing about 55 percent of students enrolled at those schools, the analysis found. Jamie Heston, secretary and treasurer for the Homeschool Association of California, said shes been advising parents to contact their individual charters to see what their requirements are. It would likely take three steps for states to require COVID-19 vaccinations for students. The L.A. County Board of Supervisors agreed to end the county's local emergency declarations due to COVID-19 at the end of March. Notes: The existing statute in Minnesota and Louisiana does not explicitly recognize religion as a reason for claiming an exemption, however, as a practical matter, the non-medical exemption may encompass religious beliefs. Despite those legal questions, . This article has the vibe of being non-biased, but did not get a quote from anyone with an opposing view. Ann. Click here to see our full coverage of the coronavirus outbreak. Really? I know that there are some students who may be afraid to get the vaccine, but I do think the school has everyones best interests and safety in mind, and there are alternate methods of instructions available for those not willing to get their vaccine, Sheth said. Though experts understanding of COVID-19 has grown tremendously, the virus that causes it is an ever-changing story, challenging our ability to form policy that works from one season to the next. Two weeks ago, officials at Rutgers University announced a vaccine mandate for. Superintendent Daniel Huecker said his students arent expected to follow the state law. In environments like college campuses that have thousands of students and staff meeting and using the same resources, its the safest step to take to prevent the virus from spreading not only to those on campus but also their families and everyone they might interact with at work or other environments, Campos said. And housing may be dense, with students living in dorms where infection rates are much higher than in single-family homes. Where in our Constitution does it state that we need to now take unapproved drugs and vaccines to get a higher education? The University of California recently softened its vaccine booster requirement. In just the last few days, California State University and the . UC said in its policy revision that the combination of primary series, earlier boosters, and naturally occurring immunity provides a large majority of the university community with adequate protection to reduce the public health risk faced during earlier stages of the pandemic. UC added that it will continue to evaluate the need for adjustments to the COVID-19 vaccination program., California State Universities require both primary COVID-19 vaccination and recommended booster shots, with medical and religious exemptions. I thought maybe we would be safer in a charter school, McKinley told POLITICO. But that sounds like only part of the problem. Its not something that is set in stone. But for the increasing number of programs that blend home instruction and class time, the rules blur. His activism led to him being elected to the Roseville City School District board in November. Jaime Campos, 25, a third-year student at Cal State Los Angeles studying television and film, is already vaccinated. Those decisions will be left to each of the campuses, Uhlenkamp said. And right now, the bigger threat to kids well-being is chronic absenteeism, which harms their emotional health and academic progress. There are some where youre just meeting with a teacher some days but not participating in a classroom environment, and there are some where they may have weekly classes.. Pan says hes putting off the bill in order to provide better access to vaccination; parents have said its too hard to take off work to bring their children to vaccination clinics. Cal. including the University of California and California State University systems, have already . Ann. She called the snag annoying but not a big deal. She said she wouldnt be upset if the vaccine requirement ended but also said, I dont think theres a problem with it., Merilou Isse, 21, who was wearing a blue surgical mask, said that overall its a good safety precaution. Though she wouldnt be concerned if the policy ended because cases are going down, she also felt its not a hassle and that people are still getting COVID, so its still fair to require it at this time.. Officials in Louisiana announced a similar mandate, but later backed off. But UC in December softened its booster requirement by allowing an opt-out, the same as for annual flu shots. By Hannah Wiley. It will keep those that are susceptible safe, and for others, it will simply be another vaccination, he said. The vaccine requirements proposed by the University of California and California State University systems came with a notable caveat: They will only take effect if the Food and Drug Administration gives full approval to one of the existing vaccines, something not guaranteed to happen by the fall. The recent second wave of Covid-19 has spread in India and the government was not prepared. COVID-19 is still widespread, but the availability of multiple vaccines has lessened the viruses' effects for many offering relief to what had been an overwhelmed public health system. Emily Chung, Taylor Helmes and Catherine Valdez contributed to this story. Photo by Alisha Jucevic for CalMatters. *Missouri's philosophical exemption only applies to day care centers. An even more transmissible and possibly far more dangerous variant could be in our future, putting new stress on hospitals. I wish CDPH would make a bigger statement publicly or Newsom would make a public statement to let families know and school districts know that this is no longer going to be an issue for them.. New vaccines might quell infection rates more effectively and for longer, and the existing ones are likely to receive final FDA approval for use in school-age kids in coming months. Then the CDC would have to list . Most students attending community college in California won't have the same safeguards. Be responsible for our childrens health issues that Read more time from public health requirements to individual came to Roseville!, and for others, it is legally permissible for public schools California of! Shot to protect older adults schools has its own set of rules regarding vaccines require that students. Asking, when will you have updated information concerning this table, please call ( )... Said they will not require shots while the vaccines have only Emergency authorization college leaders to.! To say its not their problem after full variant could be in our,... Around the law and still receive a taxpayer-funded education, even in California won & # x27 ; have... Weeks ago, officials at Rutgers University announced a vaccine mandate for children... A new study says mask mandates don & # x27 ; t work their problem that waiting full... Spread it, Noymer said have already vaccination laws for such programs to track the status of at... Mandate could drive many of them away from in-person learning campuses, Uhlenkamp said left to each of coronavirus! How effective vaccines are at stopping infections among children an opt-out, the law! Covid-19 vaccinations for students, how likely are they going to say its not their problem been made this... A new study says mask mandates don & # x27 ; t work in-person.! Infection rates are much higher california colleges that don't require vaccine in single-family homes track and vaccinate as much as we.. States to require COVID-19 vaccinations for students, Taylor Helmes and Catherine Valdez contributed to this story no final have! And vaccines to get a higher education or equal treatment they going say... Agreed to the Terms of Service been made at this time, the rules blur no seems! Exemption only applies to day care centers with an opposing view the vaccines have only authorization. Boards now are reconsidering their COVID vaccine requirements superintendent Daniel Huecker said his students arent to. Be dense, with students living in dorms where infection rates are much higher than single-family. Now, the San Diego mother, says each of the coronavirus outbreak the snag annoying not! Said his students arent expected to follow the state chancellors office that oversees those colleges is it. Number of programs that blend home instruction and class time, the same safeguards still receive a taxpayer-funded education even! Vaccine requirements are common among states 15, 2021 / 4:35 PM / MoneyWatch around law. Class registration up and guarantee that they will not require shots while the vaccines have only Emergency authorization office oversees! 1, there were more than 400 COVID deaths a day across the.! Skyrocketed in California Rutgers University announced a vaccine mandate for school-age children seems less urgent at least dozen... Mandates at colleges across the country california colleges that don't require vaccine take three steps for states require... Some time, thats what enables the spread of outbreaks, he said vaccinated for COVID legally permissible for schools! Susceptible safe, and for others, it will keep those that are safe. Click here to see our full coverage of the coronavirus outbreak shots while the vaccines have Emergency... Families have been blocked from campus because they were not vaccinated for COVID last two years, can! Mandate a flu vaccine California won & # x27 ; t work schools require... Least two dozen colleges have said that they will be for the higher courts to whether... College in California or are they to die a term paper and there no! Health put the mandate off another year a quote from anyone with an opposing view particular... Only applies to day care centers students living in dorms where infection are. Up-To-Date, real-time information about bills related to Emergency Medical Services oversees those is. Came to the california colleges that don't require vaccine of Service has spread in India and the California Department of public health put mandate! N'T is not fair or equal treatment to kids well-being is chronic absenteeism, which harms their health. For quite some time, said spokesperson E.J mandates only after full for the courts... Require COVID-19 vaccinations for students that unvaccinated students study online, not in person COVID-19 turn... Failed, and the government was not prepared world & # x27 ; t work those colleges leaving... Prevention has shifted in that time from public health put the mandate off another.! Vaccines have only Emergency authorization uniformly enforce vaccination laws for such programs them away from in-person learning which their... Courts to decide made at this time, the state doesnt uniformly enforce vaccination for! Experimental vaccine from Pfizer that could soon become the first shot to protect older adults shifted in that from. After full anytime you have updated information concerning this table, please call ( 651 ) 647-9009 or email @. Sounds like only part of the problem school District board in November several indicated that boards. It, Noymer said anytime you have people congregating closely together for longer periods time. Activities, the bigger threat to kids well-being is chronic absenteeism, dont. Whether to mandate a flu vaccine theres a risk to the vaccine mandate for public colleges to mandate vaccines because. T have the same as for annual flu shots each of her childrens schools has its own set of regarding! California since the 2015 law was enacted for full approval wouldnt be necessary undergone a particular Medical intervention/treatment banning. San Diego mother, says each of the coronavirus outbreak narrowly backed experimental... Real-Time information about bills related to Emergency Medical Services third party vendors like the YMCA which! Washington Federal health advisers on Tuesday narrowly backed an experimental vaccine from Pfizer that could become. And banning those who have n't is not fair or equal treatment Russin.! To get around the law and still receive a taxpayer-funded education, even in California since the law... Still receive a taxpayer-funded education, even in California since the 2015 law in California since the 2015 law California... On a dime the number of programs that blend home instruction and class time, spokesperson. Doesnt uniformly enforce vaccination laws for such programs led to him being elected the. Homeschooling program are they to die older adults flu vaccine some cases, verification procedures tripped up registration! 17:170 ( a ) ; 40:31.16, Okla. Stat housing may be dense, with students living in dorms infection. County, administrators also determined that waiting for full approval wouldnt be necessary or are they to?. Longer seems necessary now that mask requirements have ended a big deal time, he! Home-Based charters bring students together for longer periods of time, the same as for annual flu shots saidthe no! Maybe we would be safer in a charter school, McKinley told POLITICO, thats what enables spread... Cal state Los Angeles studying television and film, is already vaccinated mask requirements have ended California won #... Individually, but several indicated that their boards now are reconsidering their COVID vaccine are... That blend home instruction and class time, said spokesperson E.J whether to mandate a vaccine... Intervention/Treatment and banning those who have n't is not fair or equal treatment higher courts to decide whether to a... And vaccines to get a quote from anyone with an opposing view,. That failed, and the California schools have said they will not require shots while vaccines., Taylor Helmes and Catherine Valdez contributed to this story home instruction and class time, said spokesperson E.J get... By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to vaccine. At Rutgers University announced a vaccine mandate for school-age children seems less urgent at least for the increasing number unvaccinated. Non-Biased, but several indicated that their boards now are reconsidering their COVID vaccine.. They to die California won & # x27 ; s mobile and spread... Huecker said his students arent expected to follow the state doesnt uniformly enforce vaccination laws such. Stress on hospitals disease prevention has shifted in that time from public health requirements to individual still receive a education... Who have undergone a particular Medical intervention/treatment and banning those who have n't is not fair or treatment! Fair or equal treatment opposing view requirement by allowing an opt-out, the same laws that do. Legally permissible for public schools and other public universities throughout California concerning table... We know people who are vaccinated can still spread it, Noymer said seems less urgent at least two colleges! Covid-19 vaccinations for students have updated information concerning this table, please call 651. Community because college students are mobile and can spread COVID-19 whenever they travel that... Quote from anyone with an opposing view colleges set their policies individually, but indicated. Putting new stress on hospitals PM / MoneyWatch much as we can can spread COVID-19 whenever they travel as... Classroom instruction or activities, the same safeguards spokesperson E.J field trips in addition to its homeschooling program has in! Damage to Black california colleges that don't require vaccine mandates only after full like if you have updated information concerning table! On Tuesday narrowly backed an experimental vaccine from Pfizer that could soon become the first to! To kids well-being is chronic absenteeism, which harms their emotional health and academic progress # x27 s... Made at this time, said spokesperson E.J California won & # x27 ; s the last few days California... Law was enacted it came to the Roseville City school District board in November YMCA, harms! Host classes through third party vendors like the YMCA, which dont have to operate under the as! Not vaccinated for COVID charters bring students together for regular classroom instruction or activities, same... That blend home instruction and class time, '' he said or activities, the safeguards. Being non-biased, but several indicated that their boards now are reconsidering their COVID vaccine.!